Which Mattress Toppers Are Best?

A cushioning layer can make your bed more comfortable and can also ease tension on joints. But which mattress toppers are best?

Dr. Holliday Bell recommends this organic choice for those who want the firm support and the comfort of memory foam but don't want to use chemicals. It has a removable cover, and the firmness options allow the majority of sleepers to find their comfort.

1. Sleep Innovations Gel Memory Foam Topper

The topper is soft and comfortable for most people, yet still provides support. Our testers loved the way it conformed to their bodies, giving support in all the proper places. It is also a good fit for most mattresses although it's difficult to get the sheets on (read more about how to put on thin mattress topper toppers here). Its thick memory foam layer is machine-washable and naturally anti-bacterial. It also features an upholstered cover made of bamboo that is sustainably sourced and hypoallergenic. It was a popular choice of our panelists, but it's important to keep in mind that it doesn't come with straps to attach the top of your bed as it can shift as you sleep.

The panelists that loved this topper also appreciated the way it helped with their back pain. It's a great choice for sleepers with heavier weights who might consider a mattress with three to four inches will alleviate pressure on areas that are sensitive like shoulders and hips.

A memory foam with a copper-infused layer helps to wick away heat and encourages airflow to provide you sleep cool. Our tester Jaclyn found the topper to be firm enough to relieve the pressure on her back, front and side sleeping positions but not so firm that it felt uncomfortable. She also noticed a massive difference in her back pain she said it "pretty pretty much went away over night." She was impressed by how quiet the waterproof mattress topper is, as well, even when paired with a soft spring mattress. It also stops motion transfer, which makes it a great choice for couples who share the bed.

2. Coop Home Goods Retreat

We adore the soft and luxurious feel of Coop Home Goods' mattress toppers, so when this spot-clean-only version came up in our research we knew that it had to be part of. It's made of the crosscut memory foam and the microfiber blend of the brand, which makes it hypoallergenic. This is perfect for anyone looking to upgrade a soft orthopedic Mattress topper, or to refresh a bed in a guest room, dorm or rented. This topper is unique because it has five zones of different densities. It conforms to your body and provides enough support.

This topper's cover is made of 100 percent microfiber polyester that has been brushed, and it features a baffle box construction that creates pockets of fill to keep it evenly dispersed. It also has four elastic straps at each corner to keep the cover securely on your mattress. A layer of copper-infused memory foam draws heat away from the body to keep you cool in the evening and is topped with a second 2" layer of memory foam that is ventilated for even more breathability.